I Rewrote Our Story With a Better Ending
On paper, I finally said the thing and stayed for the answer.
The last thing I ever said to Daniel Okafor was "Send me pictures of the castle," which is a remarkable sentence to carry for eleven years, considering what I meant was "Stay." He was holding a boarding pass to Edinburgh and I was holding a coffee I never drank, and somewhere between security and the smell of cinnamon pretzels, I chose the castle.
We had been best friends for six years by then. The kind of friendship where his mother saved me a plate at Christmas. The kind where he once drove four hours because I said I was fine in a voice he did not believe.
Everyone assumed we were together. We corrected them with a speed that should have been diagnostic.
He got a job in Scotland. I helped him pack. I wrapped his grandmother's teapot in my own sweater because we ran out of newspaper, and I remember thinking, say it now, say it while your hands are busy... and instead I said, "This teapot is ugly," and he said, "It's heritage ugly," and we laughed, and the moment closed over like water.
At the airport he hugged me for four seconds too long. I counted. Then he said, "Well," which is what men say when they are also not saying something... and I panicked and asked for pictures of a castle I have still never seen.
He met someone in Edinburgh within a year... Of course he did. People like Daniel do not stay unclaimed on the shelf. I went to no wedding because there was no wedding, just a quiet civil thing and a photo of him in a gray suit that I looked at once, thoroughly, the way you press on a bruise to confirm your own ownership of it.
For a decade I told myself the feeling had been small. A crush... weather... nothing structural.
Then two winters ago I could not sleep, and at three in the morning I did the thing insomniacs do, which is scroll until the internet hands you an assignment. It was a page of writing prompts, and one of them said: Write the conversation you never had. Do not leave until someone answers.
I want to be honest about what happened next, because it was not beautiful. It was clerical. I got a notebook from the kitchen drawer, the one for grocery lists, and I sat up in bed and wrote the airport again. The pretzel smell. The coffee going cold in my hand. And this time, on paper, I let myself say it: "Don't get on the plane until I tell you something. I love you. I have loved you since the teapot. Probably before the teapot."
And then, because the prompt insisted, I stayed for the answer.
That was the part I had never done, not even in daydreams. In daydreams you say the brave thing and then cut away, roll credits, let the swelling music handle the rest.
The prompt would not let me cut away.
So I sat there in my own bed at 3 a.m. and made paper Daniel respond, and the first thing paper Daniel said was, "Why are you telling me this at the gate?"
Which is exactly what he would have said. Which is when I started crying.
I wrote the scene again the next night. And the next. I wrote it maybe thirty times over that winter. In one version he laughs with relief and misses the flight and we get pancakes. In one version he is angry, actually angry, that I waited until the last four seconds of six years. In one version I say it at Christmas instead, with his mother in the next room, and everything is different and we have a dog now.
The grocery notebook filled up. I bought a real one.
Regret is just a story you refuse to finish. So I finished it, every way it could go, and it turned out only one of the endings was true.
Because here is what all that rewriting taught me, and I resisted it for at least twenty drafts: the version that felt true, the one my hand kept steering back toward no matter where I started, was not the pancake version. It was the one where Daniel goes very still, and looks at his boarding pass, and says, "I know. I think I've always known. And I still have to go."
The first time I wrote that line I put the pen down like it was hot.
Because he would have gone.
Edinburgh was not a whim, it was his whole shape finally finding its slot, and the woman he married is, by every account, the sort of person you would want operating on your heart, which is convenient, because she does that for a living. My confession would not have rewritten his life. It would only have made him carry my silence out loud, across an ocean, for both of us.
I had spent eleven years believing I lost him because I was a coward. The notebook taught me something more complicated: I was a coward, and also it would not have mattered, and both of those things could sit in the same sentence without one canceling the other. There is a strange mercy in that. My therapist calls it grief work. I filed it under healing and let the two of them argue.
Last spring, one of the airport versions had turned itself into something almost like an essay, and on a brave Tuesday I posted it, names changed, on a community wall for writers. Strangers were kind. One woman commented that she had a castle of her own, a person she had waved off with some idiot sentence, and that she was going to try the notebook thing. I sat with my phone in my lap and felt useful in a way I cannot fully explain.
And then in June, Daniel came home for his father's seventieth. There was a barbecue. There was his gray-suit wife, who is funny, of course she is funny. At some point he found me by the cooler and said he had read something online that a mutual friend sent around, names changed, and he looked at me for a long moment over a lemonade neither of us was drinking.
"You got my line right," he said.
Not which line... He did not need to say which line.
We stood there while the barbecue went on being a barbecue behind us, and it was sad and it was fine, and those two things sat in the same sentence, the way I had finally learned they could. Then his wife called him over to settle an argument about charcoal, and he touched my shoulder once, and went.
The notebook lives on my nightstand now, mostly retired. Sometimes I still write scenes from memory and give them better endings, but I have noticed the endings I write these days are quieter. Less pancakes, more lemonade.
I never did get a picture of the castle. I looked it up once, on a night I was feeling sturdy. It is beautiful, obviously. It sits on a dead volcano and has survived twenty six sieges, which as of this year is exactly one fewer than the number of times I wrote the airport, said the thing, and stayed, at last, for the answer.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.