The Family That Didn't Come to My Book Launch
Forty chairs, my name on a banner, and the front row empty.
I reserved the front row with a handwritten sign that said FAMILY, and it stayed empty for the entire hour.
The bookshop had forty chairs. I know because I helped the owner, Mr. Fernandes, carry them up from the storeroom that afternoon, and he counted them out loud like a man dealing cards. Forty chairs, a folding table with a jug of water, and a banner above the till with my name on it in a font I would never have chosen, and which I have since come to love the way you love anything that witnessed your worst evening.
My first book. Fifty-one poems, six years of my life, a spine thin enough to hide behind a finger. The launch was a Saturday at six. I had told my family a month in advance, then two weeks in advance, then that morning, calibrating each reminder so it would not sound like begging, which of course meant every one of them sounded exactly like begging.
My father said what he had been saying for six years: "And what will you get from all this?" It is a question with no answer he would accept, because the true answer is nothing he counts. My mother said she would try... which in the currency of my mother converts to no. My brother had a thing. The thing was never specified. My aunt, who I invited mostly to fill a chair, said poetry was for people whose houses were already in order.
I set out the FAMILY sign anyway.
Hope is a poor planner but a stubborn one.
At 5:40 the shop held Mr. Fernandes, his cat... and me. By six, strangers had started to drift in, eleven of them eventually, choosing seats with that careful physics by which strangers maximize the distance between bodies. Eleven people in forty chairs looks worse than an empty room.
An empty room is a fact. Eleven people is a verdict.
And the front row, with its sign, stayed bare... Nobody sat there. Strangers are respectful of a reserved sign in a way that still puts a stone in my throat when I think about it: eleven people honoring a claim my own blood had declined to make.
I read anyway.
This is the part I want to tell you about, because everything before it is just hurt, and hurt is common. I stood up with my thin book and my printed remarks, and I read the first poem to the eleven, and my voice did fine until poem four, which is about my father's hands, and there I looked up out of instinct, to the seat where he should have been, the way you check a mirror that has always hung in a certain spot. Empty chair... By the window, the streetlight just coming on behind it.
I got through the poem. Readers learn to finish lines the way waiters learn to carry four plates: it is not grace, it is repetition.
Afterward there were samosas that outnumbered the guests, and eleven strangers who bought, among them, nine books.
A retired schoolteacher in the second row asked me to sign hers to "Leela, who also wrote once." A college kid asked how I got the poems out into the world, and I told him the unglamorous truth: I lost a monthly poetry contest five times before anything of mine placed, and the placing changed less than the losing did. The losing taught me to come back. He wrote that down, which alarmed me. Somewhere a young man has "the losing taught me to come back" in a phone note, attributed to a poet whose family skipped his launch.
Mr. Fernandes stacked the chairs himself and would not let me help. At the door, holding the cat, he said the only wise thing anyone said that night: "The ones who come are the audience. The ones who don't are the material."
You can spend your whole life reading to the people who did not come, or you can look up and read to the ones who did.
I wish I could tell you I learned that lesson on the spot. I did not.
I went home and sat in the dark with my phone, doing the arithmetic of grievance, drafting messages I did not send. For a while afterward I wrote angry poems, and they were bad, because anger in a poem is like salt in dough: necessary, invisible, and ruinous in the amounts I was using. It took months, and a lot of reading about loneliness, before I could admit the more complicated truth: my family did not stay away out of cruelty. They stayed away out of fear of a room where they would not know the rules, where their son had built something they had no shelf for. My father has attended exactly one event with printed invitations in his life, and it was his own wedding, and he still describes it as an ordeal.
Understanding is not the same as excusing. The chair was still empty.
Both things stay true, and learning to hold both is most of what hope turns out to be: not the belief that people will change, but the refusal to let their absence write your ending for you.
Here is how mine actually went.
A few months after the launch, a small feature ran online, one of those pages that collects writers nobody had heard yet, a paragraph and a photograph and one poem each. I was between a teenage girl who wrote about her grandmother's sewing machine and a night-shift security guard who wrote in a notebook between rounds. I mention it because that page did what the banner could not. It traveled. It did not need anyone to find parking or sit in a room with strangers. It arrived in pockets.
It arrived, specifically, in my mother's pocket, forwarded by a neighbor with the message "Isn't this your boy?"
My mother has never once discussed the launch with me. We do not have the technology. But on my next visit home, she asked, with the elaborate casualness she reserves for things that matter, whether I had "a spare copy of the book, for the neighbor." I gave her one. The neighbor, I learned much later... never received it.
I found it the following winter, when my mother was in the kitchen and I went to fetch her shawl.
The book was under her pillow.
Not on the shelf, not in the cupboard of things displayed for guests. Under the pillow, where you keep what you actually need. The spine was broken in one place, and I did not have to open it to know which poem it fell open to, but I opened it anyway, and stood there in my parents' bedroom holding the proof: page thirty-one, the poem about her, the corner of the page gone soft as cloth from being turned.
I put it back. I have never mentioned it. Some readers you get in rows of chairs, with wine in paper cups and your name on a banner. Some you get one at a time, in secret, at the rate of one page per night, six years and one empty front row later.
I still have the FAMILY sign. It lives in my desk drawer, folded once. I thought about throwing it away and found I couldn't, and it took me a long time to understand why. It is the only piece of writing I have ever put out into the world that eventually, in her own way, on her own schedule, my mother answered.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.