My Uncle the Failed Novelist Taught Me Everything
He never published a word and never wasted one either.
My uncle wrote one novel for thirty-one years and made two cups of coffee every morning for a person who never arrived. I asked him about the second cup exactly once, when I was nine, and he said, that one is for the reader. Then he drank both, which at nine I found hilarious... and at thirty-nine I find almost unbearable.
Prem Chacha worked at a bank in Lucknow for his entire adult life, in a branch where the ceiling fans moved at the speed of continental drift. Six days a week he counted other people's money, and every night from ten to midnight he sat at a green formica table and worked on a novel called The Ledger, about a bank clerk who begins keeping a secret second ledger recording not transactions but everything the customers say while they wait. He started it before I was born. He introduced himself, cheerfully, at weddings, as the family's failed novelist, the way another man might say cardiologist.
The family treated his writing the way you treat a harmless limp. My father called it Prem's homework. My grandmother, until the end of her life, believed he was studying for an exam and occasionally asked when the results were due. He absorbed all of it with the same expression, a kind of amused patience, and went back to the green table.
I was the only one who got invited to the table.
Every Sunday of my adolescence I took the number 12 bus to his flat, and he made the two coffees, and we sat with the manuscript between us. Those Sundays were my entire education. Not school, that. This.
He taught me that adjectives are loans and most writers are overdrawn. He taught me to read every sentence aloud, because the ear catches the lie before the eye does, and he would make me read my schoolboy poems standing up, like a witness. He taught me that boring is the only unforgivable sin, that sentimentality is just dishonesty with better manners, and that if you are not slightly ashamed of how true a line is, it is not true enough yet.
Years later I paid actual money to be taught writing properly, courses, feedback, a whole academy of it, and it was excellent, and almost every lesson landed with a small click of recognition: a man in a banian at a green table had already said this to me, for free, with coffee.
One Sunday when I was sixteen and full of myself, I asked him the cruel question.
If you know all this, why has nobody published you?
He stirred his coffee for a long time... Both cups.
Failure, he said, is just the word people use for a love they cannot see the money in.
I wrote it off, at sixteen, as the kind of thing losers say. I am writing it here, at thirty-nine, because it turned out to be the truest sentence anyone has ever said in my presence, and I want it to outlive both of us.
He died two winters ago, at the green table, pen capped, which the doctor called sudden and which I have chosen to call punctual. And because grief assigns homework, it fell to me to clear out the flat.
The Ledger was in the bottom drawer. Finished.
Not abandoned, not trailing off into notes. Finished, typed, retyped, the final page dated nine years before his death. Nine years it had sat in that drawer, complete, while he told wedding guests he was the family's failed novelist and drank the reader's coffee himself.
Underneath it was an envelope from a Delhi publisher, dated 1989... A rejection. Three sentences, no signature, the third sentence misspelling his name. Prem Chacha, who taught me that the ear catches the lie, who could quote Manto and Cheever from memory, who revised single paragraphs for a month, had submitted his life's work exactly once, to exactly one publisher, thirty-odd years ago, and taken one form letter as the industry's final verdict.
He never sent it anywhere again.
I sat on the floor of his flat and was angrier at him than I have ever been at any living person. All those Sundays he drilled courage into me. Send it out, he would say, shoving my poems back across the table, a poem in a drawer is a rumor.
When I finally worked up the nerve to enter my first piece into a monthly poetry contest, he asked after the result for weeks like it was a cricket score. And the whole time, his own book lay under a thirty-year-old form letter like a man buried under a bus ticket.
The last thing in the drawer was the dedication page. I had never been allowed to see it; he kept it clipped apart from the rest, superstitiously. It said: For the boy who asks better questions than editors.
There is no twist where I tell you the book got published and the world wept. Publishing does not owe the dead any tidiness. I typed all four hundred pages of The Ledger into a document over eight months of nights at my own table, fixing nothing, because he would have haunted every comma. Some publishers have it now. They are taking their time, which he would find funny. One reader at a small press wrote back to say the clerk's secret ledger made her cry on a train, and I printed that email and put it in the drawer where the rejection used to live. The arithmetic is now even, one to one. He was a banker. He would respect a balanced account.
What I did publish was an essay about him, about how he taught me that timid writing fails politely and honest writing fails forward, the same argument I later found made better on a blog about why safe poems lose. Strangers wrote to me about their own uncles, their own green tables. It turns out most families keep one: a person whose devotion never converted into evidence, and whom everyone quietly files under failed. I have stopped using the word. I have met successful writers who taught me nothing and a failed novelist who taught me everything, and I know now which ledger records the truth.
Regret, for me, is not that he died unpublished... It is that he died unread, and that the distance between those two things was one stamped envelope he could not bring himself to send, and that I, who ask better questions than editors, never asked him the only one that mattered: Chacha, what are you afraid of? I was too busy being taught to notice my teacher bleeding.
So here is what remains. Every morning, before I write, I make two cups of coffee. My wife thinks it is charming and slightly deranged, and she is right on both counts. One cup is mine. The other sits across the table, going cold next to the empty chair, and I write toward it.
That one is for the reader, he said.
He was the reader. He was always the reader.
Every word I have ever gotten right was poured, hot, into the second cup.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.