Writing on Commute Time: 60 Poems From One Train Line
A contest judge argues the commute is the best writing room you will ever get, with a three-stop drafting method, a worked line edit, and the case for terrible rooms.
The 7:42 into the city smelled like wet coats and someone's cinnamon gum. A man two seats down argued into his phone about a fridge delivery. Under those conditions, over fourteen months, I drafted sixty poems, and eleven of them turned into work I would still defend. So when poets tell me they cannot write until life gives them a quiet desk and an empty morning, I push back hard. Writing on commute time is not the compromise version of a practice. For many of us it is the practice, and the train, the bus, the twenty-minute walk to the office is a better writing room than the one you keep waiting for.
Why Writing on Commute Time Beats the Quiet Desk
Here is the uncomfortable truth I learned from my own notebooks: the quiet desk invites performance. You sit down with your good pen and your good intentions and you try to write A Poem, capital letters and all. The pressure of the dedicated hour produces dedicated-hour poetry, which is often stiff, self-conscious, and over-plotted from the first line.
The commute removes that pressure by force. You have eighteen minutes, a jolting seat, and a stranger's elbow. Nobody, including you, expects a masterpiece. And the moment the expectation drops, the language relaxes. You stop writing what a poem is supposed to sound like and start writing what you actually noticed: the fridge argument, the gum, the specific gray of the river under the bridge.
There is also the matter of material. A desk gives you your own head, which you have already read. A train car gives you forty strangers, overheard sentences, weather moving past glass at speed. Half the images in my commute notebooks I could never have invented at home, because at home nothing was happening.
What Motion Does to a Line
Something specific happens to syntax when your body is moving and your time is short. Sentences compress. You reach for the concrete noun first because you might not get a second clause. Compare a draft line I wrote at my desk with the version the train gave me a week later.
Desk version:
I look out the window at the passing trees
and think about how quickly my life is going by.
Train version:
The trees run backward.
Somewhere a version of me
stays behind at every station.
The desk version explains a feeling. The train version enacts one, and it does so partly through the line breaks, which mimic the lurch and pause of the carriage itself. If you want to understand why those breaks carry so much of the poem's motion, the entry on enjambment in our glossary is worth ten minutes of your next ride. Movement outside the window teaches movement inside the line. I have never found a faster tutor.
The Three-Stop Method
After a year of trial and error, my commute drafting settled into a shape I now teach. It assumes a ride of fifteen to forty minutes, divided by stops or landmarks rather than by the clock, because stops are physical and clocks are abstract.
- Stop one: collect. From boarding until the first major stop, you are forbidden to write a poem. You only list. Five things you can see, two things you can hear, one thing you can smell. No adjectives yet. "Cinnamon gum" beats "a sweet smell" every time.
- Stop two: collide. Pick the two least related items on your list and force them into one sentence. The fridge argument and the gray river. The gum and the funeral suit. This collision is where most of my keepable first lines have come from, because it bypasses the obvious.
- Stop three: commit. For the remainder of the ride, draft downward from that sentence without stopping to judge. When your stop is announced, you write one more line standing up, coat on, bag on shoulder. That last line, written under eviction, is disproportionately often the best line of the draft.
Three rides gives you three raw drafts. One in five will deserve a desk revision on the weekend. That ratio sounds low until you do the math: a five-day commute is ten rides a week, which is eight rough drafts and roughly two poems worth developing, every single week, out of time you were going to spend refreshing a feed.
Walkers, adjust rather than abandon. Replace stops with corners: the first corner is collect, the second is collide, and the front door is commit. A colleague of mine drafts entirely on a twenty-two minute walk to the office and swears the footfall rhythm settles her into iambs before she has noticed a single image. Bodies keep time, and meter is only time made audible, so let the walk conduct.
Phone or Notebook: Settle It Once
The tool argument wastes more commute writing time than any train delay, so settle it once and stop renegotiating. Both work. They just fail differently.
- The phone is always with you and types fast, but it is also a casino in your pocket. If one notification can pull you out of a draft, and for most of us it can, put the phone in airplane mode before you board or do not use it for drafting at all.
- The pocket notebook has no notifications and forgives bad handwriting on a moving train, but drafts die there unless you transfer them. Give yourself a standing Sunday rule: everything worth keeping gets typed up, everything else gets a strike through it.
- The voice memo is the underrated third option for drivers and cyclists, who should obviously never write by hand or thumb in motion. Speak the list, speak the collision line, transcribe at lunch. Spoken drafts come out with a natural cadence that typed drafts often lack.
Whichever you choose, keep it reachable without unzipping anything. A tool that takes forty seconds to deploy loses to an image that lasts ten.
A poem does not need your best hour. It needs your honest twenty minutes.
A Draft I Scored Last Spring
Last spring I scored a contest entry that I would have bet money was a commute poem, and the poet's note confirmed it: drafted on the number 12 bus over three consecutive mornings. It followed a school kid rehearsing a speech under his breath, and it ended on the poet missing her own stop because she wanted to hear the ending. Nothing in it was invented, and everything in it was chosen. It placed in the top ten that month. Since Writory shows every entrant a score breakdown across creativity, emotion, structure, language, and theme, I can tell you exactly where it won: language and emotion, the two criteria that reward noticing over decorating. The poems I forget are usually written about life. The poems I remember are usually written inside it, and the bus is about as inside it as you can get.
From Train Draft to Finished Poem
A commute draft is ore, not jewelry. Do not submit Tuesday's 7:42 draft on Tuesday night. Let it sit until the weekend, then revise at an actual desk, where the performance pressure that ruins drafting is genuinely useful for polishing. Read it aloud. Cut the first two lines, which on commute drafts are almost always throat-clearing while the train pulled out. Check that the stranger you borrowed is rendered with dignity, since they never agreed to be material.
Then test it against readers who owe you nothing. Our writing tips section covers revision in more depth, and when a piece survives your own scrutiny, sending it to a monthly contest gives you something a drawer never will: a stranger's verdict and a deadline for the next one. Deadlines, like train schedules, are just externalized discipline, and commuting poets are already fluent in schedules.
The Argument for Terrible Rooms
Poets have always worked in unsuitable rooms. William Carlos Williams drafted between patients on prescription pads. Wallace Stevens composed on his walk to the insurance office and dictated to his secretary on arrival. The unsuitable room is not the obstacle in these stories. It is the mechanism: constraint made them choose, and choosing is most of the craft. If constraint as a generative force interests you, the compressed logic of the haiku makes an ideal commute form, small enough to finish between stations.
So stop apologizing for drafting on a train, and stop waiting for the writing life with the oak desk and the long silence. That life may come. But the 7:42 leaves tomorrow morning either way, and it is carrying forty strangers, a river, and eighteen unclaimed minutes. Some poet is going to use them. I would rather it were you.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.