The Prose Poem, for Poets Who Think It Is Cheating

A judge who used to dismiss prose poems explains what changed his mind, where the form actually lives, why most prose poems fail in the same two places, and a one-evening test to find out whether yours is a poem or a paragraph.

For the first four years I judged, I quietly downgraded every prose poem that landed in the pile. I told myself I was being fair, but the simple fact is: I did not trust a poem that did not show me its line breaks. If it looked like a paragraph, I read it like a paragraph, and paragraphs almost never win against a well-made stanza.

Then a poem changed my mind, and it did it the way these things always change a judge's mind: by being so obviously good that my prejudice became the only thing standing between it and a win. It was a page-long unbroken block about a father's hands, and when I read it out loud it had a pulse no line break could have given it. I have thought about that poem every judging season since.

Where the form actually lives

A prose poem is not a paragraph wearing a poetry costume. It is a poem that trades the line break for a different instrument: the sentence. In a lined poem, the break is where meaning turns. In a prose poem, the turn has to live inside the sentence itself, in rhythm, in repetition, in the moment a long sentence suddenly snaps into a short one.

That is the trade. You give up the line break's clean cuts and you get, in return, the ability to run continuous pressure. The best prose poems feel like a held breath that keeps getting tighter. The worst feel like an essay that lost its conclusion.

The two failure points I see every round

Failure one: it is a chopped paragraph. The poet took a piece of prose, removed the line breaks, and called it a prose poem. There is no compression, no sentence rhythm, no turn. It reads like a memo. This is the most common form and the easiest to spot: read it out loud and it sounds like a text.

Failure two: it is a lined poem with the breaks removed. The poet wrote a normal poem, deleted the returns, and submitted it as prose. The joins show. You can feel where the lines used to be, like seams under wallpaper. A real prose poem was born as a paragraph; it was never anything else.

Between these two failures sits the real form: a piece of writing that would be worse with line breaks, not better.

The one-evening test

Here is how I tell a real prose poem from a disguised one, and you can run the same test on your own work tonight.

Step one. Take your prose poem and add line breaks. Put them wherever the sense seems to want them. If the poem improves, it was a lined poem wearing a costume. Break it properly and submit it as one.

Step two. If adding breaks makes it worse, because the sentences needed to run into each other to breathe, you have a real prose poem. The form is doing work.

Step three. If adding breaks changes nothing, if the piece reads the same either way, it is not a poem in either form. It is a piece of prose. That is not a failure; it is information. Write it as a story instead and it may win in a different category.

A worked example

Here is a sentence that could only live in a prose poem, not a lined one: My mother kept her wedding ring in a tea tin labelled 'loose change' and the tin in a drawer labelled 'things to fix' and the drawer in a house that outlasted the marriage by twenty-two years.

Break it at 'change' and the rhythm collapses. The sentence has to run, because the running is the point: each container holds the next, and the sentence is the container that holds them all. That is a prose poem's move, and it cannot be made with a line break.

Where it sits in a contest

Prose poems enter the same pile as everything else, and they win when they do what lined poems cannot. If you are tempted, do the one-evening test first. If it survives, send it. If it wants line breaks, give it line breaks. The contest window does not care about the shape; it cares about the pressure. If you want more on choosing form, the poetry forms library has a sister entry on the prose poem's cousins, and the Academy covers form choice in the craft module.

Keep reading

For the craft side, the prose-poetry module covers the deeper method. The free-verse module is the page to read next, and the story contest is where the work goes when it is done.

By Writory Editorial, for Writory.

Keep reading in the Writory Library

Enter a Writory poetry contest