I Quit for Five Years. How to Start Writing Again
A contest judge who stopped writing for five years shares the way back: why the identity trap keeps poets silent, a six week reentry plan, and an honest look at the first ugly poem home.
The last poem I wrote before the silence was about my daughter's first tooth. Then came a job with a two hour commute, a move, another move, and a morning five years later when I found my old typewriter in a storage box and realized I had not thought of myself as a poet in a long time. Not blocked. Just gone. If you want to start writing again after years away, I can tell you exactly how I got back, because I have since coached dozens of returning poets through the same door, and the door is nothing like what you fear it is.
How Five Years of Silence Actually Happens
Nobody quits poetry on purpose. There is no resignation letter. What happens is quieter and more sensible: a season gets busy, and you tell yourself you will write when it calms down. The season becomes a year. Then the habit of not writing develops its own gravity, because now writing would require admitting how long it has been, and that admission stings, so you postpone it the way you postpone calling an old friend. The longer the gap, the heavier the phone.
A woman in one of my workshops described her twelve year silence perfectly: she said the notebooks moved house with her three times, and every time she packed them she felt a small ache and did nothing about it. That is how it happens. Not a slammed door, just a box, taped shut, carried carefully from address to address, waiting.
I want you to notice something about that story: at no point did you stop being able to write. You stopped being willing to feel the awkwardness of restarting. Those are wildly different problems. One would take years to fix. The other takes about twenty minutes, once, and then it is done.
The Lie That Keeps You From the Desk
The returning writers I coach all carry the same sentence: I am not really a writer anymore. It sounds like humility. It works like a padlock. Because if you are not a writer, sitting down to write feels like impersonation, and nobody volunteers to feel like a fraud on a Tuesday evening.
Here is the correction, and I mean it literally, not as a pep talk. Writer is not a status you hold or lose like a gym membership. It is a description of what you are doing while you are doing it. The five silent years did not revoke anything, because there was nothing to revoke. There is only the next twenty minutes, and whether a pen moves during them.
You do not go back to being the writer you were. You arrive as the writer the silence made.
How to Start Writing Again: Small, Ugly, Daily-ish
Every failed comeback I have witnessed, including two of my own before the one that worked, followed the same script: the poet returned with a masterpiece plan. A sequence. A chapbook. Something ambitious enough to justify the absence. It collapses within a fortnight, every time, because you are asking cold muscles to lift their old maximum, and when they fail, the failure feels like confirmation of the padlock sentence, and the silence gets another year of funding.
The comeback that works is embarrassingly small. My first poem back was four lines about the smell of the typewriter ribbon, and it was bad. I have kept it, the way you keep the wristband from a hospital stay. Small proved the pen worked. Ugly proved I could survive being bad at the thing I loved, which is the actual test. Daily-ish, meaning four or five times a week without self-punishment for gaps, proved it was a practice and not an event.
The Six Week Reentry Plan
This is the sequence I give every returning poet. Six weeks, no step skipped, ambition strictly rationed.
- Week one: read poetry for pleasure, ten minutes a day, and write nothing. You are restoring the appetite before you cook. Choose poets you loved before the silence and one you have never read.
- Week two: copy poems out by hand. One a day, someone else's, word for word. This sounds mechanical and is quietly transformative: your hand relearns the shape of lines without any pressure to invent them.
- Week three: write one haiku a day. Three lines is a door anyone can fit through, and the form forces the exact skill rust destroys first: concrete observation.
- Week four: expand two of those haiku into poems of eight to twelve lines. You are not creating from nothing now. You are developing, which is easier and builds the same muscle.
- Week five: revise, and pay attention to where your lines end. Returning poets break lines timidly, at every comma. Push one break somewhere that creates suspense. If the term is fuzzy after the years away, the refresher on line breaks takes five minutes and repays it fast.
- Week six: finish one poem and show it to one person or one contest. Not because it is ready. Because the loop of write, share, learn is the engine, and the engine needs all three strokes to run.
A Worked Example: My First Real Poem Back
I promised honesty, so here is the actual evolution. Week four, first attempt: Five years went by and I did not write, / and now I sit here trying to remember how, / hoping the words will come back to me. Every returning poet writes this poem. It is a status report, not a poem: three abstractions holding hands.
Week five, after forcing myself toward objects: The ribbon still smells of iron and church basements. / I type my name to see if it survived the box. / It did. The e sticks. So do I. Same subject, but now there is iron, a basement, a sticking key doing the emotional work. The revision took one instruction: replace every sentence about writing with a sentence about a thing you can touch. Steal that instruction. It converts more comeback drafts than any other advice I give.
What Changed While You Were Gone
Now the part nobody tells returning writers, the part I would put on a billboard. The five years were not a hole in your development. They were the development. While the pen was capped you accumulated the one resource poetry cannot fake: lived material. Jobs, losses, cities, a marriage weathered or ended, the specific texture of ordinary years. The poet who left the desk had opinions about grief. The one who returns has inventory.
I see the proof monthly in contest scoring. On our five criteria breakdown, the one every entrant receives whether they win or not, returning writers routinely post their highest marks in emotion and theme, the two categories that cannot be studied for, and their lowest in structure, which can be rebuilt in weeks with the plan above. That trade is heavily in your favor. Technique is teachable. A decade of witnessed life is not.
- Your taste kept growing. Taste develops from reading and living, and it never stopped. This is why your old drafts now look flawed to you: not because you got worse, because your standards got better.
- Your subjects matured. The obsessions you left with have either deepened or resolved, and both outcomes make better poems than the originals would have.
- Your urgency is real now. Nobody restarts after five years out of habit. You came back because something needs saying. That pressure is worth more than fluency.
The Door Was Never Locked
On the far side of my own comeback, here is what strikes me most: the five years of staying away were harder than the twenty minutes of coming back. I spent half a decade guarding a door that was never locked, and I meet poets every month doing the same vigil.
So put this piece down and write four bad lines about the nearest object with a history: the mug, the jacket, the box the typewriter slept in. That is the whole assignment. In six weeks, when something finished exists, send it where honest strangers will read it closely; a contest that scores every entry and shows you the breakdown is the fastest mirror a returning writer can find. And when someone asks how long you have been writing, you will be allowed the answer I use now, the one that took me five silent years to earn: on and off, my whole life. The off matters less than you think. The on can start tonight.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.