How to Deal With Poetry Rejection
Quick answer: How to deal with poetry rejection: what a no actually means, how working poets handle the maths of submissions, and when a rejection carries a signal.
Deal with poetry rejection by treating it as data, not verdict: log it, resubmit the poem elsewhere within a week, and keep enough work in circulation that no single reply matters too much. A rejection means one small group of readers did not choose this poem for this issue, nothing more. It does not mean the poem is bad, and it certainly does not mean you are.
That is easy to write and harder to feel at 7 a.m. with a form email open on your phone. So it helps to know the base rates. Respected journals accept somewhere between half a percent and three percent of submissions. Editors who later became famous rejected poems that became famous too. The system is a lottery with skill mixed in, and everyone who plays it collects noes by the drawer-full.
Read the rejection for its actual information
Rejections come in tiers, and the tier is the message. A standard form letter carries no information about quality. A form letter with a personal line added, we enjoyed these, please send more, is a genuine signal; editors do not type that for everyone. A named poem singled out, or an invitation to submit again, means you were close and should send new work to that journal within a few months.
What a rejection almost never contains is advice. Journals do not have time to explain, so resist inventing an explanation on their behalf. The poem may simply have arrived the week they accepted three other elegies.
Build a system that absorbs the blow
Poets who last are rarely the thickest-skinned; they are the best organised. A submission tracker does emotional work: when a no arrives, your next action is already defined, which is to send that poem to the next venue on its list. Rejection becomes a step in a process instead of an event in your life.
Some poets also seek out venues that say something instead of nothing. Feedback-oriented contests exist for exactly this reason; Writory scores every single entrant across five criteria, so even a losing entry tells you whether structure, language or emotion was the weak leg. One number you can act on beats ten silences.
When rejection is trying to tell you something
One exception deserves honesty. If a poem has been declined fifteen or twenty times across a sensible range of venues, the market has voted. That does not mean delete it; it means take it back to the desk. Often a much-rejected poem has a strong middle wearing a weak opening, or an ending that explains what the images already said. Revise it as if someone else wrote it, then start its submission list from zero. Some of the best published poems are rejected poems that went home and changed.
What poets can take from this
- Log every rejection the day it arrives, then queue the poem for its next venue.
- Never reply to a rejection in the first hour of reading it.
- Treat any handwritten or personal line from an editor as an invitation to submit again.
- Keep ten or more poems in circulation so each decision is one of many.
- After roughly fifteen noes, revise the poem seriously before resubmitting.
- Celebrate submission counts, which you control, not acceptance counts, which you do not.
Try it yourself
Write a poem addressed to a door that keeps closing, in which the speaker slowly realises they have been knocking on the wrong building.
Questions
Do all poets get rejected?
Yes, including the ones on prize shortlists. Acceptance rates at good journals sit in the low single digits, so a poet with a strong publication record is usually a poet with hundreds of rejections behind it.
Should I revise a poem after every rejection?
No. One or two noes are noise, not feedback. Revise when a poem has accumulated many rejections across varied venues, or when your own rereading finds a fault, not because a single journal passed.
Is it rude to submit again to a journal that rejected me?
The opposite: editors expect and welcome it, especially if they added an encouraging line. Wait for the next reading period, send new poems, and mention briefly that they encouraged you to try again.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.