The Rejection Email I Printed and Kept
One personal line at the bottom changed my entire trajectory.
There is a rejection email taped above my desk, and it has outlasted two apartments, one marriage of a houseplant to a windowsill, and every acceptance I have ever received. People see it and assume it is some kind of revenge shrine. It is the opposite. It is the kindest thing a stranger ever did for me, and it took her eleven words.
In the autumn I turned twenty-nine, I decided to take submissions seriously. I had been writing poems for years the way some people keep a garden nobody visits, and I made a spreadsheet, because that is what you do when you want to feel professional about an activity that offers no other way to feel professional. Journals down the side, dates across the top, a column for responses that I formatted before I had earned a single one.
By March the column had filled in nicely. Nineteen rejections. I could recite the house styles by heart. There was the cheerful corporate one, we receive many wonderful submissions. The chilly one, we are unable to use your work at this time, as if my poems were a coupon that had expired. The one that arrived nine minutes after I submitted, which at least respected my schedule.
I got good at metabolizing them. Open, wince, log it in the spreadsheet, close. Ten seconds of feeling... then administration.
This is a survivable system, and I recommend it, and it slowly kills something, because you cannot armor yourself against rejection without armoring yourself against everything traveling in the same direction.
Rejection twenty arrived on a Tuesday in April, from a small journal called Driftway that I had admired for years. Standard opening. Thank you for sending us your work. After careful consideration, we have decided it is not the right fit. Wince, spreadsheet, ten seconds. I was reaching for the close button when I saw there was one more line, below the signature, in that slightly apologetic way a postscript sits on a page.
P.S. The last stanza of “Inventory” kept me up past midnight. Send us more. R.
I read it eleven times.
I counted, later, because I am the kind of person who keeps spreadsheets.
Eleven words, if you do not count the initial. Somebody named R had read my poem, and it had followed her to bed the way poems had always followed me to bed, and she had taken the time to say so at the bottom of a form letter, at what I imagined was the end of a long day of saying no.
I did not log it in the spreadsheet. There was no column for it.
Instead I printed it, which felt absurd even while the printer was doing it, this office ritual for a rejection. I took a pen and underlined the postscript, and then, because the underline did not seem like enough, I copied the whole line out by hand on the back of an envelope, just to feel each word pass through my arm. There is a photograph on my phone of that envelope, the ink close up, the letters wobbling on “midnight.” I have deleted a decade of photos and kept that one.
Here is what those eleven words actually did, mechanically, to a person who was quietly deciding to quit... Because I was. I had told no one, but nineteen rejections into that spreadsheet, I had started drafting the sensible speech, the one about how the garden was always meant to be private anyway.
A rejection with your name spelled right and one true sentence at the bottom is not a door closing. It is a door left open exactly one inch, and one inch is all a serious person needs.
The postscript did not say my poem was publishable. It said my poem had done, to one professional stranger, the only thing I had ever actually wanted poems to do. Everything else, the credits, the spreadsheet, the feeling professional, was scaffolding around that. R had seen the building inside the scaffolding and left a note on it.
So I sent more. Not just to Driftway, though Driftway took a poem the following year and I may have said nothing coherent for an hour afterward. I sent everywhere, differently now, because the sending had a face attached. Every journal contained a possible R, someone reading at midnight, hoping... actually hoping, that the next file would keep her up. I stopped submitting the way you buy lottery tickets and started submitting the way you write letters. When I entered a monthly poetry contest that spring, I sent the poem with the stanza that had cost me the most sleep to write, on the theory that sleep lost is a currency that transfers.
But the real turn came two years later, when a friend of a friend asked if I would volunteer as a first reader for a small journal. Unpaid, unglamorous, eighty submissions a month. I said yes mostly out of curiosity about the other side of the door.
Reader, the other side of the door is a hallway with eight hundred doors.
I had imagined editors as gatekeepers, arms crossed. What I found was tired people reading on lunch breaks and trains, genuinely rooting for every file they opened, declining work they liked because the issue was full, or the tone was wrong for spring, or the poem was good and two others were better. I learned that “not the right fit” is usually the plain truth rather than a euphemism. I learned, from actually studying the craft in a way my pride had never permitted before, how often my own early submissions had been almost, and what a wide, populated country almost is.
And I learned what R’s postscript had cost. On an eighty-submission month, at eleven words each, personal notes are a tax you pay out of your own evening. Most readers cannot afford it often.
Which meant she had not been following a policy that Tuesday.
She had made a small, unrequired decision about a stranger.
So I started paying it forward, deliberately. Not on every decline, I am not a saint, and some poems are simply not there yet. But when a piece kept me up, I said so, under the signature, where the true things go. P.S. The third stanza of your poem stayed with me on my walk home. Send us more. I never once found out what happened on the other end of those notes... That is the design of the thing. You leave the door open an inch and walk away.
Except once. Last year, at a reading in another city, a young poet I had never met read a piece about hope, the durable kind, hope as a practice rather than a mood, and afterward she mentioned, offhand, that she had almost quit three years ago, until an editor scribbled one line at the bottom of a rejection. She had printed it, she said. It was taped above her desk.
It was not my journal... and it was not my line. Some other tired reader, some other midnight. That is the part that undid me. There are Rs everywhere, a quiet unpaid network of them, holding doors open an inch all over the world, and none of them ever finds out which of us walked through.
The email above my desk has gone yellow at the edges. The tape has been replaced four times. Nineteen rejections came before it and I could not quote you one of them.
But I can tell you exactly what kept a stranger up past midnight.
And I can tell you that eleven words, spent on the right Tuesday, are the cheapest miracle there is.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.