The Runner-Up Certificate I Framed
Everyone frames victories; I framed the year I almost quit and didn't.
The frame cost more than the prize money I did not win.
Forty dollars. Walnut, real glass, the kind of frame people buy for diplomas or dead relatives. Inside it, on heavy cream paper, a certificate that announces, in a serif font doing its absolute best: Runner-Up.
Visitors always ask. There is a rhythm to it. They lean in, read it, and their face does a small polite stall, like a car in the wrong gear. "Runner-up," they say. "So... second?" Second, I confirm. "And you framed it?" I did. Center of the hallway, eye level, where other families hang wedding photos.
To explain the frame, I have to explain the year.
That year I processed insurance claims by day and processed nothing at all by night. My notebook had been untouched since February; I know because February is written at the top of a page followed by three lines and a coffee ring. In March my mother was diagnosed, and after that the calendar stopped being months and became chemo Tuesdays. Poetry felt like a hobby from a previous administration.
I could draw the oncology waiting room from memory. Eleven chairs. A fish tank with one heroic angelfish. A coffee machine that takes exact change only, as if grief ever carries coins. A watercolor of a harbor that no one, anywhere, has ever visited. The corridor smelled like lemon disinfectant laid politely over something worse.
By November I had decided, quietly, to quit writing... Not dramatically. No burning of notebooks, no announcement. I simply stopped calling myself a writer inside my own head, which is how it actually ends for most of us: not with a decision... but with a de-listing.
Then, one chemo Tuesday, my mother, mid-drip, wool hat slightly crooked, looked up from her crossword and asked what I was working on. I said nothing much. She said, "You used to write me poems for my birthday. Cheaper than flowers, and they kept." Then she went back to fourteen across like she had not just performed surgery.
Cheaper than flowers. And they kept.
That night I opened the notebook past the coffee ring and wrote about her hands. The crossword pen balanced in the right one, the IV line taped over the left, the way she filled in answers in a chair designed for despair. I had always thought poems about family needed to be soft. This one came out with eleven chairs in it, and lemon disinfectant, and exact change.
A writer friend, the only one still checking on my notebook like it was a hospitalized relative of hers, told me about a monthly poetry contest. Free to enter, real judges, results in January. I submitted it from the hospital parking lot with my phone at two percent, engine running for the heater. If the battery had died thirty seconds sooner... none of the rest of this happens.
In January, the email: runner-up.
Not the winner... Let me be clear about that, because I have made my peace with it in writing and out loud. The winning poem was better than mine. I have read it a dozen times and it wins every time.
First place got a cash prize. Second place got a certificate, a PDF, my name spelled correctly.
Everyone in my life responded with condolence energy. "So close!" "Next year!" "You were robbed." My brother, bless him forever: "Do they do recounts?"
They all assumed I had almost received something. None of them could see that I had received it entirely.
Because the certificate was never about placing. It was a receipt.
Proof of purchase for the year I almost quit and didn't.
Everyone frames the mountaintop. I framed the ledge where I stopped falling.
I printed the PDF at a copy shop on the heaviest paper they had, which cost forty cents and felt like a coronation. The teenager at the counter read it while it printed, said "congrats," and meant it more than several adults had. Then the walnut frame. Then the hallway.
My mother finished treatment that spring. She came over to inspect the certificate the week it went up, read it twice, tapped the glass with the crossword pen, and said, "Second out of how many?" A few thousand, I told her. "Hm," she said. "The judges' loss." That is objectively not how runner-up works, and it is exactly how mothers work.
Next to the certificate hangs a photograph, and this is the part visitors never ask about, because it looks like ordinary family wall material: a small black and white picture of a pair of hands holding a hardbound notebook. They are my grandfather's hands. My mother took the photo decades ago with a borrowed camera, because she wanted, she says, a picture of the notebook more than a picture of him. He wrote poems his entire life. He read them to an audience of exactly one, his wife, at the kitchen table, and published nowhere, ever.
He never entered anything... Not for lack of wanting. There were no contests within reach of his village, his language, his decade. The distance between his notebook and my certificate is two generations, one long migration, and one free entry form filled out in a hospital parking lot. When I am tempted to feel embarrassed about second place, I look at his hands and feel the arithmetic of it. He got zero readers he wasn't married to. I got a few thousand strangers and a judge who ranked me above all but one of them. Somebody in that frame ought to call that winning, so I do.
I kept going, is the point. More rejections since, naturally, arriving at their usual cruising altitude. One more shortlist. One small publication in a journal none of my coworkers have heard of, which I mention constantly. I even enrolled in a proper course on the craft, twenty years late, and discovered there are names for the things I had been doing by accident, and better versions of them I had not been doing at all.
My mother is two years clear now. The crossword pen survives. Every birthday she gets a poem, as ordered. Cheaper than flowers. They keep.
Last month a dinner guest stood in my hallway a long time and finally asked the honest version of the question: "Doesn't it bother you? Seeing runner-up every single day?" And I understood that the question is really about what we believe walls are for. Most people think a wall is for evidence of victory. Mine is for evidence of continuation.
Some mornings, in the right light, the glass over that certificate turns half mirror, and for a second I can see my own hands reflected across my grandfather's, four hands holding one notebook between them.
Nobody in that frame ever finished first.
Everybody in that frame kept going.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.