The Book Club That Never Reads the Book
Nine years strong, zero chapters finished, attendance always full.
In nine years, the Thursday Book Club has assigned one hundred and eight books and finished none of them, and our attendance record is better than most marriages.
I need you to understand the scale of the failure. We are not a club that skims. We are not a club that reads half and fakes the rest. We select a book each month with real ceremony, we vote, we argue about the vote, someone writes the title on a card and props it against the sugar bowl, and then all seven of us arrive four Thursdays later having read, on average... the back cover and possibly the dedication.
Marcus once read an entire wrong book, a thriller with a similar title, and gave a passionate summary before anyone had the heart to stop him. It remains the closest we have ever come to a literary discussion.
Outsiders assume we must talk about something, and we do. We talk about everything. Renata's disastrous kitchen renovation, which lasted longer than two of the books. The month Priya taught us all to make dumplings and the flour got into the card catalog of Frank's record collection. Whether Marcus should text his ex back (seven votes, unanimous, no). The card against the sugar bowl watches all of it like a chaperone we have learned to ignore.
For years, when people asked me what the book club was for, I made a joke of it.
Then Dana joined, and I had to find out.
Dana moved to town two winters ago for a job she described as "spreadsheets, but sadder," knowing not one person within two hundred miles. She found us through a flyer Frank had pinned to the co-op board in 2019 and never taken down. And Dana, because she is a serious person with a highlighter collection, did the thing no one had warned her not to do.
She read the book.
All of it. Cover to cover, sticky notes in three colors, questions prepared in a document. She sat down at her first meeting, opened a folder, and said, "So. I wanted to start with the ending, because I have thoughts."
The silence was extraordinary. Seven adults staring into their coffee cups like the answer might be printed on the bottom. Renata, our bravest, finally said, "Sweetheart... we have a confession."
And that is how the truth came out for the first time in nine years, spoken aloud over two coffee cups going cold on the table between Dana and me: nobody reads the book. Nobody has ever read the book. The book is, and Renata chose this word carefully, the tablecloth. Something to set everything else on.
Dana looked around the room. New town... no friends... three colors of sticky notes in a book nobody else had opened.
I watched her decide whether to be insulted.
"So what do you actually do?" she asked.
"This," said Frank, and topped up her coffee.
She stayed four hours. She came back the next month, having read, she announced with ceremony, nothing at all.
It was the fastest anyone has ever understood us. Later she told me those first Thursdays were the only two evenings that month she had spoken to another human being after six o'clock, and that she used to schedule her grocery runs at rush hour just to stand near people. I have thought about that sentence more than anything in the one hundred and eight books. There is a whole shelf of poems about loneliness that say it with more polish, but none that say it better.
Here is the part I have never written down before.
The club was born in a hospital.
Nine years ago, Renata was in the oncology ward for her first round of chemotherapy, and her sister brought her a novel to pass the time. Renata could not concentrate past a paragraph, the medication saw to that, but visitors kept asking about the book on her nightstand, and she discovered something: if she said "we can discuss it when I'm out," people came back.
The book was a hostage that guaranteed a second visit. When she recovered, she kept the trick and formalized it. A book a month, discussed never, and the same faces guaranteed to appear at her table whether there was anything wrong or not.
"I didn't want people checking on me," she told me once, rinsing cups at her sink. "Checking on you ends. I wanted a standing appointment."
We never finished a single book in nine years, but we never once ran out of things to say.
The unread books, by the way, do not go to waste. They live on a dedicated shelf in Renata's hallway, one hundred and eight spines, mostly uncracked, arranged in order of assignment. Guests assume it is a library. It is actually a diary. Renata can run her finger along it and tell you everything: this one was the month of Priya's divorce, this one was when Frank's grandson was born three weeks early and we met in the hospital cafeteria, this fat one was the month nobody suggested a meeting because we were all at Renata's anyway, every night, during the second diagnosis, the one that turned out to be a shadow on the scan and nothing more. We assigned a nine-hundred-page Russian novel that month out of pure defiance. It stands on the shelf like a war memorial.
I should mention June, because June is the exception that explains the rule. June is seventy-four, the quietest of us, and two years ago she let slip that she had been writing poems since her husband passed, and the club turned on her with the full force of nine years of unspent literary attention. She resisted... We persisted. Finally one Thursday she took a folded page from her handbag, put on her reading glasses, and read us fourteen lines about setting a table for one and getting it wrong on purpose.
It is the only text, in the entire history of the Thursday Book Club, that every member has experienced in full. We discussed it for two hours. Dana used her sticky notes. Marcus cried and blamed the dumplings. And then, because we are pushy people who love her, we spent three more Thursdays convincing June to enter it into a monthly poetry contest, which she finally did the way you would defuse a bomb, with Dana pressing the buttons and June supervising from across the room.
It did not win... June was radiant anyway. "Somebody I have never met read it," she said. "A stranger knows about my table." She has entered something every month since, and started poking through a page of prompts for what to write next, which means June, at seventy-four, is now the only member of the book club with a reading habit and a deadline.
Last Thursday we assigned book number one hundred and nine. It looks wonderful. The reviews are stunning. The card is propped against the sugar bowl.
Nobody will read it, and everybody will come, and that, after nine years, is the entire point.
The books were never the appointment.
We were.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.