The Letter I Finally Sent to Myself
Everything I needed to hear, in my own handwriting, posted properly.
I have written hundreds of kind letters in my life, and until last spring, not one of them was addressed to me. Condolence cards that made widows phone me in tears, birthday notes people framed, a reference letter so warm the recipient read it at her own wedding. Meanwhile the voice I used on myself would have gotten me fired from any job involving other human beings.
My therapist noticed this before I did. Her name is Maren, she keeps a small cactus on the windowsill that we have both agreed not to discuss, and one gray Thursday in March she interrupted me mid-sentence.
I had just described a small mistake at work, a misdated invoice, nothing, and the words I used about myself were "useless" and "embarrassment" and one other word I will not print.
"Would you say that to Priti?" Maren asked. Priti is my best friend since we were eleven.
"Of course not."
"Why not?"
"Because it would be cruel. And untrue."
She let that sit in the room for a full ten seconds... which in therapy time is a geological era. Then she gave me the homework I had been dodging for months, the exercise I had privately filed under things for people softer than me. The internet calls them self compassion exercises, which had always made me picture scented candles and lying to yourself in a mirror. Maren's version had teeth.
"Write yourself a letter," she said. "Not a journal entry. A letter, with a greeting and a signature. Then put it in an envelope, put a stamp on it, and post it. Properly. To your own address."
"That's ridiculous. I'll know who it's from."
"You'd think so," she said, and smiled at the cactus.
The first draft was sarcastic. Dear Disaster, congratulations on surviving another week of your own company. I brought it in almost proudly and Maren read it and said, "You wrote this with an audience in mind. Who were you performing for?" Which ruined sarcasm for me as a hiding place, possibly forever.
The second draft was worse: a to-do list wearing a letter's clothing. Dear me, here is everything you should fix. Maren handed it back. "That's not a letter. That's a performance review."
"Then I don't know how to do this," I said, and my voice cracked on "know," which told both of us more than the drafts had.
She suggested a workaround so simple it felt like cheating. Write the letter to Priti, she said. Imagine everything that happened to you this year happened to her instead. Same facts. Her name at the top.
So one night in April, at my kitchen table, with the radiator ticking and a mug of tea going cold in that way tea does when you finally start telling the truth, I wrote to Priti. I told her the invoice was nothing. I told her that what she called laziness that year was actually grief with its coat still on, that nobody recovers from the winter she'd had on schedule, that the way she kept showing up anyway was not weakness but the most stubborn kind of courage.
I told her I had watched her be merciless toward herself for two decades, since we were girls, since long before either of us knew where she had learned that voice, and that the sentence she kept repeating about herself was originally someone else's sentence, spoken over a report card in 1994, and it was allowed to expire.
Four pages. My hand ached.
Then I did the thing Maren told me to do.
I crossed out Priti's name at the top and wrote my own.
And I read the whole letter again, out loud, alone in my kitchen at 11 p.m.
I am not going to be able to describe what that was like with the dignity intact, so here it is without: I put my head down on my own kitchen table and cried the way you cry when someone finally says the thing...
Except no one had said it.
I had written every word myself, about myself, and had believed all of it for the entire length of four pages because I thought it was about somebody worth defending.
The kindness had been in me the whole time. It just refused to come out unless it thought it was for someone else.
The turn I did not expect came after. Because the assignment was not finished.
The assignment said: post it.
I almost didn't... Reading it once felt like the achievement; the envelope felt like theater. But I had come this far being obedient, so I copied it out fresh, no crossings-out, sealed it, addressed it to myself like a lunatic, and stood at the postbox on Harcourt Street for a stupid amount of time... before letting go. There is a specific sound a letter makes falling into a postbox. I had never once listened to it before.
It arrived on a Saturday, three days later, and here is what Maren knew that I did not: a posted letter arrives in the future, to whoever you are that day. And the woman who picked it up off the mat that Saturday was having a genuinely rotten morning, a canceled plan, a bathroom scale, a phone call with my mother that went the usual direction, the works. She was not the composed woman who had written it.
She needed it.
And because it came through the letterbox with a stamp and a postmark, because it sat in the pile between a utility bill and a pizza menu, some deep bureaucratic part of my brain processed it as real correspondence. External. Admissible. My own handwriting looked, for four pages, like the handwriting of someone who knew me completely and had decided, with full information, to be gentle. I have received love letters that did less.
I read it standing in the hallway in my dressing gown. Then I read it again sitting on the stairs. The sentence that undid me was not the grand one about courage. It was small: "You made everyone's tea before your own for thirty years. Sit down. The kettle can wait for you for once."
Some things have changed since, and honesty requires me to report the size of the changes: small. The cruel voice did not vanish; it just stopped being the only voice with a microphone. When it starts up now, there is a second voice with equal authority, and I know it is equal because I have documentary evidence in blue ink. Maren says forgiveness toward yourself is not one decision but a correspondence, and you have to keep answering. So I write one every few months now. The last one started as one of those writing prompts, "write to the person you were at nine," and turned into three pages about a report card, and a girl at a kitchen table in 1994, and everything that childhood voice got wrong about her.
Posted that one too. The sound is familiar now.
The first letter lives in the drawer with the passports and birth certificates, which was not a deliberate choice, but I have decided it is a correct one: documents proving who I am. The folds have gone soft from opening. Close up, you can see where the ink feathered on the word "gentle," because my hand was shaking there, just slightly, the way a voice shakes when it finally says something true out loud for the first time.
I know the letter by heart now. I keep it anyway. Some mail you answer for the rest of your life.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.