We Divorced Kindly
Nobody teaches you how to end a marriage with tenderness.
My wife proposed our divorce the way she once proposed marriage: over breakfast, holding my hand, absolutely sure. There was marmalade on the table and the radio was playing something with violins, and Maya looked at me and said, "I think we're finished, and I think you think so too."
Here is the terrible thing. My first feeling was relief.
My second feeling was grief about the relief, and my third was a wild, childish urge to defend us, twelve years of us, the flat we painted twice, the dog we chose from a shelter because he was the one not barking.
But she was still holding my hand. She had not let go to say it.
That detail undid me more than the sentence.
"Okay," I said... It came out steadier than I was.
Nobody had cheated. I want that on the record, mostly because everyone we told went looking for the crime. My mother asked who the other woman was. Her brother asked me, over a pint he insisted on buying, what I had done. Our friends split into investigative teams. It seemed to genuinely unsettle people that a marriage could end without a villain, as if we had reported a burglary where nothing was missing.
But something was missing. It had been missing for a while. We had become excellent flatmates, world class colleagues in the small corporation of our household. We ran the dishwasher at optimal times. We forwarded each other articles. We said love you at the ends of phone calls the way you say it to a landline dial tone, out of muscle and history. Somewhere around year ten we had stopped arguing, and I used to brag about that until I understood what it meant: we had stopped arguing because neither of us believed there was anything left to win.
I read an essay once, long after, about why safe poems lose, how a poem that risks nothing cannot move anyone, no matter how technically clean it is. I sat with that for a whole evening, because that was us. We had revised all the risk out. We were a beautifully punctuated poem that no longer made anybody feel anything, including its two authors.
So we decided, since we were ending it, to end it the way we had failed to live it: deliberately.
Maya took the yellow legal pad we used for holiday packing lists and wrote RULES at the top, and underlined it twice, because she is Maya. The rules were: no lawyers used as weapons. Nobody storms out to sleep at a friend's place to make a point. We tell both mothers together, in person, on the same weekend, so neither family gets a head start on a version of the story. And rule four, which she wrote smaller than the others: we are allowed to be sad in front of each other.
Rule four turned out to be the hard one.
It is a strange intimacy, dismantling a life with the only other person who knows where everything is. We divided the records one Sunday with coffee and it took six hours because every third sleeve was an argument against the whole project. She found the ticket stub from our second date inside a Nina Simone album... and neither of us said anything for a while. The dog, Biscuit, went with her, because her new place had a garden and because when we did a blind test of calling him from opposite ends of the park, he chose her, the traitor, and we laughed so hard a jogger checked on us.
I will be honest, because kindness without honesty is just performance. There was one night I did not manage it. Alone in the half emptied flat, surrounded by the pale rectangles where her pictures had hung, I raged. I said cruel things to the kettle. I begrudged her the ease of her certainty, the garden, the dog's decision. Kindness, I learned that night, is not a feeling that descends on the lucky. It is a discipline you keep on the nights the feeling does not come.
On our last night in the flat we did the thing I have never told anyone but strangers.
We wrote unvows.
It was her idea, obviously. We sat at the kitchen table where everything important had ever happened to us, two coffee cups between us because we had already packed the wine glasses, and we each read a page out loud. I promise to stop expecting you to be the person I invented at twenty six. I promise to remember your parents' anniversary without you reminding me. I promise not to make our friends choose. I release you from my mother's opinions. She read hers steadily until the last line, which was, "I promise that leaving you is not the same as regretting you,"... and then neither of us was steady at all.
Nobody teaches you that some loves do not fail. Some loves simply finish, the way good books finish, and the ending is not a betrayal of the story.
The courthouse took eleven minutes.
The clerk had the gentle, bulletproof cheer of a man who processes endings all day, and because we came in together, laughing at something from the car park, he pulled the wrong pad toward him and asked if we were here for a marriage license. We looked at each other and Maya said, "Other direction," and the clerk apologized so profusely we ended up comforting him.
Afterward we went to the diner where we had our first date, because we are sentimental in exactly the same broken way, which is possibly why we lasted twelve years and possibly why we did not last twenty. We ordered what we ordered in 2011. The waitress, seeing something in our faces, asked if we were celebrating.
"Yes," we said, at the same time, and the strange part is we meant it.
People want me to say the kindness made it hurt less. It did not... It hurt with terrible precision, actually, because there was no anger to hide inside. Anger is insulation. We had chosen to grieve without it, and some mornings that felt like walking out in January without a coat. What the kindness did was simpler: it meant that when the hurting was done, there was nothing else to clean up. No scorched friendships. No secrets rotting in a group chat. Just two people who had told the truth slightly too late, and then told it properly.
In the year after, I did something I had not done since school. I started writing things down. It began with the unvows, which I kept, and it turned into notebooks, and eventually into poems I never showed her, most of them circling forgiveness, which surprised me, because I had assumed there was nothing to forgive. There was. Not a crime. Just years of mutual, comfortable cowardice, and it turns out you can forgive a thing that small and that enormous. One about starting again in middle age is the first thing I ever published anywhere, under my own name, which frightened me more than the courthouse did.
Maya remarried two summers ago. I was invited. I went. Her mother, who has never fully accepted the situation, cried at me instead of the ceremony and said, "It should have been you," and I said, gently, because it was true, "It was me, Ana. I already had my turn."
We still meet once a year... Not on the wedding anniversary, which belongs to who we were, but on the anniversary of the divorce, which belongs to what we managed to become. Same diner. Same booth if we can get it. Two coffee cups on the table between us, hers with lipstick on the rim, mine with too much sugar, and for one hour we are fluent in a language only two people on earth ever spoke.
The waitress does not ask anymore if we are celebrating.
She just brings the cups.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.