The Family Group Photo Took Four Hours
Forty relatives, one photographer, and a grandmother who kept blinking on purpose.
The photographer quit at hour three, and my family considered this a personal weakness on his part.
It was my grandparents' fiftieth anniversary, which in our family meant a rented lawn, a buffet with two kinds of paneer, and the ceremonial assembling of all forty of us into one photograph, a task roughly equivalent to herding cats, if the cats were related to each other and several of the cats were not currently speaking to two of the other cats.
The photographer's name was Ramesh. He arrived at four in the afternoon with a tripod, a flash umbrella, and the doomed optimism of a man who had photographed corporate retreats. He said, and I will never forget this, "Group photo first, then everyone can relax."
Forty heads turned toward him with gentle pity.
The first twenty minutes went to assembly. You cannot simply arrange my family by height. There is a protocol older than the republic. Grandparents seated center. Eldest uncle to Dadaji's right, except the eldest uncle was in the parking lot arguing with a caterer about ice. Second uncle refused to stand next to third uncle over the matter of a Diwali card that had allegedly arrived without a name inside it, an insult now entering its fourth year of litigation in the family courts, meaning the kitchen. The toddlers moved through the formation like weather. Someone's phone kept ringing with a devotional song at full volume, and someone else kept answering it.
At minute forty, Ramesh achieved the impossible. Forty people, arranged, dressed, facing forward. He raised his hand. "Ready! One, two..."
My grandmother blinked.
Not a flutter. A full, committed, both-eyes closure, held like a fermata, so that in the frame she appears to be peacefully asleep in the center of her own anniversary.
"Once more," said Ramesh. No problem. These things happen.
She blinked in the second one too.
And the third. In the fourth, she achieved something I did not know was physically possible: she blinked and turned her head, so she appears as a serene blur, a woman mid-teleportation, while forty descendants around her smile at nothing.
Understand who my grandmother was at this point in the story: the family's undisputed head, four foot eleven, hearing selectively perfect, a woman who could split a mango with her hands and end an argument with one eyebrow. She had raised six children on a schoolteacher's salary and once chased a monkey off the roof with an umbrella and a tone of voice.
Nothing about her blinked involuntarily. Nothing about her did anything involuntarily.
But nobody suspected. You do not suspect your grandmother. You adjust the lighting.
So we adjusted. Hour two was diagnostics. My cousin the engineer suggested the flash was triggering her reflexes, so Ramesh turned it off, and in the flashless photo she blinked anyway, majestically.
An aunt suggested she count to three, so we counted to three, all forty of us, in unison, like the world's largest hostage video, and Dadi closed her eyes precisely on two. The toddlers began to cry in shifts, an organized labor action. Second uncle and third uncle, united for the first time in four years by shared suffering, stood shoulder to shoulder and forgot to resume their feud, which no one dared point out in case it broke the spell.
Hour three: Ramesh, sweating through his shirt, proposed the modern solution. Burst mode. Thirty frames per press. "Statistically," he said, with the hollow confidence of a drowning statistician, "her eyes must be open in one."
He fired off ninety frames. In eighty-eight of them... my grandmother's eyes are shut.
In the other two, the baby is falling.
That is when Ramesh quietly packed his umbrella, accepted his payment plus a plate of paneer, and left, wishing us, and I quote, "all the very best." My family watched him go and agreed among themselves that photographers these days lacked stamina.
It was my father, in the end, who balanced someone's phone on the tripod, set a ten-second timer, and sprinted into the frame. And in that photo, the last one of the day, taken in fading light with half the fairy lights on, my grandmother's eyes are wide open, bright as anything, because the game was over and she had won.
I only learned it was a game two years later.
I was staying with her during my exams, and we were going through the anniversary album, and I said, teasing, "Dadi, you blinked in every single one."
She turned the page without looking up and said...
"I know."
I waited... She smoothed the plastic sheet over the photograph with one finger, over all forty of us, and said, "The moment the photo comes out correct, everybody leaves. The chairs go back to the tent house. Your uncles stop standing next to each other." She tapped the picture of the two of them, shoulder to shoulder, feud suspended. "Four hours, everybody stayed in one place. When does that happen? You think I was going to give that up for one, two, three, smile?"
She blinked on purpose because a finished photograph scatters a family, and an unfinished one holds it together.
I have thought about that sentence for years, and I have never gotten to the bottom of it. It is the closest thing to a philosophy my family has ever produced. We do not say we love each other. We show up in impossible numbers and stand in the heat, complaining, for four hours, and we call the complaining a memory afterward. Years later, when I started writing seriously, the first poem I finished that felt true was about her thumb smoothing that plastic sheet, and I found there was a whole shelf of poems about family that circle this exact thing: love that never announces itself, love that just refuses to let the group disperse.
Dadi turned ninety last March. Same lawn. Same two kinds of paneer. A new photographer, a young woman with a mirrorless camera who finished the group photo in eleven minutes because the family has thinned and softened and learned to cooperate, which is its own kind of sad.
But here is what happened in the first frame, and I promise you it was not planned, or at least not by anyone under eighty. The photographer counted to three, and all forty of us, cousins in from three countries, uncles with new knees, toddlers who are now taller than me, every single one of us blinked... On purpose. On two.
The photographer lowered her camera, bewildered. My grandmother looked down the rows of her descendants standing there with our eyes shut like a choir of the deliberately asleep, and she laughed until she had to sit down, and that sound is the thing I am actually trying to photograph every time I write anything about what we keep.
The eleven-minute photo came out perfect. It is framed in her hallway.
Nobody looks at it.
The one we pass around, the one that gets reprinted every time a cousin gets homesick, is the first frame. Forty people, eyes closed, one grandmother mid-laugh, nobody leaving.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.