I Read His Old Love Poems at Our Wedding
The ones he wrote at nineteen, terrible and perfect.
I committed a small theft three weeks before my wedding, and my victim was the groom.
His mother was my accomplice. She led me into the garage with her phone flashlight because the bulb had died sometime around 2009, shifted a crate of Christmas lights, and pulled out a shoebox with DANIEL, PRIVATE written on the lid in marker gone brown with age.
"He would kill me," she said, handing it over like contraband. "Read them anyway."
Inside were forty one poems Daniel wrote when he was nineteen. I counted. Forty one poems on loose leaf, on the backs of physics worksheets, on a napkin from a diner called The Blue Comet, all of them terrible, all of them about a girl named Priya who worked at the campus library and, as far as I can tell, never once learned his name.
I sat on the cold garage floor... and read every single one.
They were bad in the specific way only teenage poems are bad. He rhymed fire with desire twice in the same poem. He compared her eyes to "twin lakes of umber mystery." One poem was just the word why written eleven times, each one bigger than the last, and honestly... that one almost worked.
But here is the thing nobody tells you about reading someone's old love poems: the girl does not matter.
Priya is a shape, a placeholder, a coat rack. What is actually on the page is him. Nineteen year old Daniel, who felt so much he had to put it somewhere, who wrote "I would carry your books through any weather" and meant it with his whole undeveloped frontal lobe.
I was not jealous of Priya. I was jealous of the paper.
Because my fiancé, thirty four year old Daniel, did not write poems anymore. He wrote emails with subject lines like "Quick sync on Q3."
He was kind and steady and funny in a dry way that took strangers a month to catch. But somewhere between that shoebox and me, he had decided that feeling things loudly was a phase, like the earring, and he had quietly retired it.
I had seen the old voltage exactly once. Three years earlier, at his grandfather's funeral, he stood up without notes and said, "He taught me to fish, and I hated fishing, and I would give anything to be bored in that boat one more time." Then he sat down.
Eleven seconds.
It was the best eulogy I have ever heard, and I fell for him a second time in a funeral home in November, which is not where you expect that to happen.
So three weeks before the wedding, sitting on a garage floor with a dead spider and a box of a stranger's feelings, I made a decision that our future marriage counselor, if we ever need one, will hear about eventually.
I stole six poems. The six worst ones. Which is to say, the six best.
The Reading
Our wedding was small, forty people in his aunt's backyard under a rented tent that smelled faintly of every wedding it had ever hosted. When the toasts started, I stood up, which was not on the schedule. My maid of honor, who I had looped in, handed me a folder like a lawyer passing evidence to the bench.
"Before I agreed to marry this man," I said, "I did some research."
Daniel's mother put her hand over her mouth. Daniel looked at her, then at the folder, then at me, and I watched him understand in real time. He said, "No," but he was already laughing, the caught kind of laugh, the kind that starts in the shoulders.
I read "Ode to the Girl at Circulation Desk Three." I read the umber mystery one. The tent went from polite chuckles to genuine crying laughter. His college roommate shouted "TWIN LAKES" and had to be patted on the back like a choking victim.
And then I read the last one, the napkin one, and the tent went quiet.
Because the napkin one was not funny. It was four lines about how he was afraid nobody would ever know him all the way down... and how he would rather be known than admired... and it took me until the third line to notice my voice had started doing the wobble thing.
"He wrote this at nineteen," I said. "In a diner, probably at two in the morning, about a girl who never spoke to him. So I want to say, for the record, in front of witnesses: I know you all the way down, Daniel. And being known and being loved are not different things. Not here. Not today."
I looked up. My almost husband, this dry, steady man who signs his emails "Best," was wrecked. Openly, gloriously wrecked, in front of his boss and both grandmothers.
Here is the turn I did not see coming.
He stood up.
He did not take the microphone so much as receive it, the way you receive a baby. Then he pulled a folded sheet of paper from inside his jacket.
"I wrote this at six this morning," he said. "First one in fifteen years. Apparently we had the same idea. So."
It was a poem. A new one. For me. And in the second stanza he rhymed fire with desire, on purpose this time, a callback fifteen years in the making, and forty people absolutely lost their minds.
Nobody writes poems at nineteen because they are good at it. They write because the alternative is exploding.
What I understand now is that the shoebox was never an archive of an old crush. It was proof of capacity. Everything scribbled on those physics worksheets was still in him, wearing a better shirt, waiting for permission.
People ask us now where we found such personal wedding readings, as if there is a website with a dropdown menu for that. There is not. There is a garage, and a mother with a flashlight, and a box you are not supposed to open.
Open the box.
A month after the honeymoon, Daniel wrote another poem and let me enter it into a monthly poetry contest. It did not win. He printed the rejection email and stuck it on the fridge like a kid's drawing, which I take as evidence that the nineteen year old is fully back in the building. Around the same time I sent him an essay about why safe poems lose, and his next one was noticeably less safe. It was about his grandfather, and the boat, and being bored on purpose with someone you love. I cried in a parking lot reading it.
The napkin from The Blue Comet hangs above our dresser now, in a frame that cost more than the meal it once wiped up. Some nights I read it before bed the way other people check their phones.
Priya, if you are out there: thank you for never learning his name. Every love poem needs a coat rack before it finds the person it was actually for. I am the person. It just took the poems fifteen years, one theft, and a backyard full of witnesses to reach me.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.