My First Poem Was a Lie About a Dog
I invented a dead pet for sympathy and discovered fiction.
The dog's name was Biscuit, and he never existed. For one entire term of fourth grade, thirty-two children and one weeping teacher believed he had died under the wheels of the morning milk van, and I stood at the front of the class in my too-big uniform and let them believe it.
It started with Mrs. Fernandes and her poetry assignment. She wrote on the blackboard in her looping cursive: WRITE A POEM ABOUT A TIME YOU WERE SAD. Then she underlined SAD twice, hard enough to snap the chalk, as if any of us might otherwise attempt joy.
The class had material. Ritika's grandmother had died in March, and she had worn a white ribbon in her plait for a month afterward, so everyone knew. Aman's father had been transferred to Bhopal and back within a year, which Aman described as losing all his friends twice. Even Dhruv, who once ate chalk on a dare, had a cousin who had fallen out of a guava tree and broken both legs, which was at least adjacent to tragedy.
I had nothing.
I was nine years old and my life was scandalously fine. My parents loved each other in a quiet, functional way. My grandparents were alive and played rummy every evening. Nobody in my family had so much as sprained anything.
That night I sat cross-legged on my bed with my diary open, chewing the end of my pencil until the wood went soft, waiting for sorrow to arrive. Downstairs the radio was playing an old Kishore Kumar song, the sad one everybody's mother loves, and I remember thinking, unfairly, that even the radio had more grief than I did.
So I did the only sensible thing.
I manufactured some.
Biscuit arrived fully formed somewhere around nine o'clock. Brown, with one white sock on his front left paw and an ear that never learned to stand up. He liked the smell of rain and was afraid of the pressure cooker. He slept at the foot of my bed, in the exact spot where, in reality, I kept a pile of comics. And on a Tuesday morning, while chasing a paper bag across the road, he met the milk van.
The poem took me forty minutes. It had four stanzas and it rhymed the way only a nine-year-old's poems rhyme, with total commitment and no shame. The last two lines were: His bowl still sits beside the door. He does not eat there anymore.
I read it aloud in class on Friday. Halfway through the second stanza I heard Ritika sniff. By the bowl beside the door, Mrs. Fernandes had taken off her glasses and was pressing two fingers against her eyelids. When I finished, the room did that thing rooms do when something true has been said in them. It went quiet in a different key.
Nobody asked the obvious question, which was how a family in a second-floor flat with a landlord who banned even goldfish had come to own a dog.
Grief, I learned early, suspends fact-checking.
At lunch, a boy named Kunal, who had never once spoken to me, walked over and pressed his best marble into my palm. It was the blue one with the twist of white inside, the one he had defended in playground disputes the way nations defend borders. He said, quietly, that his dog had also died, two years ago, and that it stops hurting... but not all the way.
Then he walked off before I could confess or thank him, and I stood there holding his marble and my lie, and both of them felt heavier than they looked.
Here is the part I have never been able to explain properly. The guilt was real, but so was something else... something bigger and more disgraceful: pride.
I had made thirty-two people feel something with a pencil.
Ritika had cried over an animal that had never drawn breath. I had invented a life so convincing that it earned a death.
A good lie, I learned at nine, is just a truth that hasn't found any other way to get itself said.
Because the poem was true. Not the dog, the dog was fraudulent from nose to tail. But everything underneath him was accurate. I was an only child in a flat where pets were forbidden, and I had wanted a dog with a want so constant it had stopped feeling like wanting and started feeling like weather.
I had grieved Biscuit for years before I invented him. The milk van just gave the grief a shape and a date.
The reckoning came at the parent-teacher meeting in December. My mother sat down across from Mrs. Fernandes, who reached over the stack of report cards, took my mother's hand in both of hers, and said she was so very sorry about the dog.
My mother, who is allergic to dogs, cats, and by her own account most forms of spontaneity, did not blink. She said thank you. She said we were managing. Then she collected my report card, complimented the school's new water cooler, and walked me home in a silence so complete I could hear my own school shoes squeaking.
I was preparing my defense the whole way. What she finally said, at the gate, was not what I expected.
She said, “From now on, you lie on paper only. Nowhere else. Paper only.”
That was the entire punishment. It took me twenty years to understand it was not a punishment at all.
It was a job description.
I kept the terms of the deal, mostly. I filled diaries. I wrote poems about heartbreaks I exaggerated and grandfathers I promoted to war heroes, and slowly, without noticing the exact day it happened, the lies started curving back toward the truth, the way a boomerang does. By sixteen I was writing about real things and using invented details to make them more honest, which sounds like a contradiction until you try it. Much later I would read an essay about why safe poems lose and recognize the whole arc of my childhood in one line: the poems that risk nothing earn nothing.
Years after Biscuit, I finally sent something out into the world. I entered a poem into a monthly poetry contest, and it was about my father's silences, and every fact in it was verifiable, and it was still, in every way that mattered, a descendant of that dead invented dog. Everything I have written about childhood since then has really been about that flat, that bed, that diary, that boy trying to feel something big enough to be worth writing down. These days when a prompt asks me to write about loss, I don't panic about having nothing. I know now that nobody has nothing. Some of us just have to build the thing before we can bury it.
I never told Kunal. He moved schools in sixth grade and took his forgiveness with him... unclaimed. I still have the marble. It sits in a small brass bowl on my writing desk, blue with a twist of white inside, condolence for a dog that never lived.
And some nights, when the house is quiet and a pressure cooker hisses in some other flat, I catch myself listening for claws on the floor. Biscuit never existed... I want to be clear about that.
But I'd know his bark anywhere.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.