The Meal My Father Made Only When He Was Sad
We learned to read his heart by what appeared on our plates.
My father never once said the word sad out loud in his life.
He said khichdi.
Not the good kind. Not the festival kind with cashews and peas and a proud puddle of ghee. His was the pale yellow, slightly watery kind, rice and dal surrendering into each other, with papad burnt deliberately at the edges and, afterward, two cups of coffee boiled with too much milk, one for him and one for whoever was brave enough to sit with him.
That was the whole menu. It never varied in thirty years. It was less a recipe than a flag run up a pole.
Growing up, my sister and I could come home, smell the pressure cooker, and know before we reached the kitchen that something in the world had gone wrong. We would take off our shoes quietly. We would not fight over the television. We were children, we understood nothing about money or mortality, but we could read a stove the way sailors read sky.
Khichdi meant the factory had cut his overtime. Khichdi meant his friend Prakash's son had gone into hospital. Khichdi, one whole silent week in 1994, meant something we never found out, and to this day my sister and I call any private sorrow "a 1994." Everyone's family has a language that never made it into any dictionary. Ours was served hot, with pickle on the side.
The strange mercy of it was that he cooked at no other time. My mother ran the kitchen the other three hundred and forty days of the year, fluent and fast. But when the sadness came, she stepped aside without a word and let him have the stove, and I understand now what a marriage was contained in that. She gave him the one room where he could say things.
He was otherwise a cheerful man, which people who write about fathers always forget to mention about the quiet ones. He told terrible jokes and rated them himself out of ten. He clapped at cricket like the players could hear him. The sadness was not his climate. It was weather, rare enough that the khichdi years stand out like pins on a map: 1989, 1994, the winter of 2003 when his brother stopped speaking to him over a strip of ancestral land not big enough to park two scooters on.
Then came an evening in 2019 when the flag went up and nothing, as far as any of us knew, was wrong.
I was visiting for the weekend. The smell reached me on the stairs, and I stood outside the door with my bag still on my shoulder doing frantic arithmetic.
Nobody had died... Nobody had called. His pension had come on the third, as always.
I walked into the kitchen and there he was, stirring, and he looked up with a smile pulled on slightly crooked, like a shirt buttoned wrong.
"Sit," he said. "It will be ready in ten minutes."
"Papa. What happened?"
"Nothing happened. A man can make khichdi."
A man can... This man could not, not innocently, and we both knew it.
But there are rules to a language, and rule one of ours was that you never asked the stove a direct question.
So I sat, and we ate, and he burnt the papad with his usual care, and we drank the too-milky coffee, our two cups on the little table between us where his newspaper usually sat, and I flew home on Monday with a stone in my stomach.
Six weeks later my mother rang. The tremor in his right hand, the one he had been hiding by keeping the hand in his pocket, by letting her pour the tea, by a hundred small choreographies we had all watched and not seen, finally had a name.
He had known since that weekend.
He had gone to the neurologist alone, on the bus, and come home, and cooked.
He told the stove before he told us. All his life, when the words would not come, my father put them in a pot and fed them to the people he loved.
The disease was slow, as these things go. We had years, and I am grateful for them in a way that has taken me a long time to say without my jaw going tight.
But the cruelty of it was specific: it came for his hands.
The stirring hand. The papad-turning hand. There arrived a day when the pressure cooker's weight was beyond him, and I happened to be there for it, and he stood in the kitchen holding the lid like a workman whose tools have been repossessed.
"Come," he said. "You do the lifting. I will supervise."
That is how I learned the recipe, if you can call it teaching. He sat on a stool and issued corrections. Less water. No, more than that. You call that burnt? Burn it properly, beta, the bitterness is the point.
When I asked him, finally, at last, forty years late, why this dish, he was quiet for so long... I thought the question had joined all the other unanswered ones.
"When my father drank everything," he said, meaning the year the family shop was lost, a year I knew only as a rumor, "my mother made this every night. It was the cheapest food that still felt like dinner. She would say, we are not poor, we are simple. Every night, we are not poor, we are simple." He tapped the stool. "It is the taste of someone deciding you will be all right."
I went home and wrote that down, and then I kept writing, badly at first. Writing about your own family while they are alive to read it is a particular tightrope, and I wobbled on it for months, until I stopped trying to make him a symbol and just put the burnt papad on the page. The poem I eventually read aloud to him made him laugh, then go quiet, then rate it. Seven out of ten. From him, a knighthood.
He died in February, on a Tuesday, gently, which was very like him. The house filled with relatives and their casseroles, the way houses do, everyone bringing rich food as if grief were a wedding. On the fourth night, after they left, my sister and I stood in our mother's kitchen, and neither of us said anything, and she got out the rice and I got out the dal.
We made it wrong. Too thick. Papad not burnt enough. We ate it anyway, with our mother between us, three people being gentle with one stove.
Here is the part I did not expect. Last month, in my own kitchen, in my own city, I had a day that folded in on itself, the kind you cannot explain to anyone because nothing happened... everything simply weighed more than usual. And I found myself, without deciding to, soaking rice. My daughter came in when the cooker whistled. She is nine. She has eaten this dish maybe five times in her life.
She looked at the pot, then at me, for a long moment... reading.
"Papa," she said carefully, "are you okay?"
Fluent already. Nobody taught her.
The language just gets in, the way languages do, through the ear, through the plate, through the steam.
"I will be," I said, and burnt the papad properly, the bitterness being the point, and poured out two cups of coffee, too much milk in both, and set them on the table between us.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.